Relief for Web Scrapers – According to the Ninth Circuit, What You Do Is Not Illegal
Ever heard of web scraping? It is also known as web data extraction or web harvesting, and these names should be self-explanatory.
But for everyone to be on the same page, web scraping is the extraction of data from websites that can either be done manually or using a software, with the latter being the automated and more common practice.
It involves the gathering and copying of specific data into a spreadsheet or database for analysis or later retrieval.
Questions over the legality of this practice have been raised ever since the advent of the internet, with opinions being starkly divided.
Luckily, the judiciary has the last laugh when it comes to legal matters, and it seems that those claiming that web scraping is legal are on the winning side.
How many anti-hacking laws do you know? You must know of the main one at least, the CFAA. In full, it is the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, and it was first enacted in 1986. Those who are against web scraping say that the practice violates this law, a claim that a three-judge 9th Cir. panel in San Francisco disagrees with.
In the hiQ Labs v. LinkedIn case that was concluded earlier this month, the judges reached the verdict that hiQ Labs were not in violation of the CFAA by scraping data from the Microsoft-owned LinkedIn.
Before the matter reached the corridors of justice, hiQ Labs had received a cease-and-desist letter from the aggrieved company, but since they felt that what they were doing was right in the eyes of the law, the went ahead with their data extraction.
In court, LinkedIn argued that because hiQ Labs continued to harvest data from their website even after receiving the cease-and-desist, the analytics company was “trespassing.” In proper internet terminology, the resumé website felt that they had grounds to sue them for unauthorized access.
One of the judges on the panel, Marsha S. Berzon, had quite the mouthful while delivering the final ruling. Likening breaking and entering to computer hacking, she admitted that the CFAA was enacted to prevent intrusion.
However, since the information on LinkedIn is available to the public, the judge found no wrongdoing on hiQ Labs’ part by harvesting and analyzing the data.
Not even the cease-and-desist could make a case for unauthorized access in her eyes, seeing as literally anyone in the world can access data from LinkedIn and analyze it in whichever way they may want.
Additionally, the software used by hiQ Labs to harvest data did not bypass any passwords or firewalls set up by LinkedIn made their argument moot, as the judge put it.
Isn’t the very description of public data the fact that is available for any and all interested parties? As such, Judge Berzon found no illegality in hiQ Labs’ web scraping.
This ruling by the 9th Circuit is a huge win for web scrappers, but their woes are far from over. The issues they face are largely due to an ambiguity in the CFAA, as the Act doesn’t clearly come out against data harvesting, nor is it openly in support of it.
It’s now up to Congress to tackle this matter once and for all, before these many suits open up a can of worms.
More in Legal Advice
Back Pain from a Slip-and-Fall Accident: Symptoms and Treatments
According to the Centers for Disease Control, about 1 out of 5 falls causes a serious injury including back pains. There...February 11, 2020
Law Students Are Using Crazy Tactics to Stay up All Night And It’s Taking a Toll on Their Health
If you are studying law right now, chances are, you are committed to the profession, and rightfully so, since you’re in it...February 11, 2020
This Grandmother Filed a Lawsuit for Suffering Emotional Trauma from Daughter’s Childbirth
Most family members are thrilled to watch their loved ones give birth, but one grandmother was particularly horrified after witnessing a traumatizing birth...February 11, 2020
Unilever Stole This Product Idea from a Scientist, 13 Years Later Justice Has Been Served
Waging a legal war against a corporate giant is no easy feat but it is a battle worth fighting for, especially when there...February 10, 2020
Thinking of Taking a Friend’s Debt to Court? Here’s What You Need to Know about a Money Claim
Your landlord doesn’t want to return your security deposit or you’ve been scammed by a seller – in both situations, the...February 10, 2020
Good Guy Turned Bad? Judge Portrayed in American Gangster Faces a Five-Year Probation Because of This SHOCKING Reason
Have you watched the 2007 film American Gangster? There’s a reason it got a series of nods from award-giving bodies: its...February 10, 2020
Are You Too Old for Law School, Here’s What You Need to Consider Before Choosing the Major
If you are here, that means you, like many others, chose a career path that has proved to be unsatisfactory. Now...February 10, 2020
‘Money Issues’ Is the Third Leading Cause of Divorce in America—Here’s How Couples Can Avoid Fighting About Financial Matters
After ‘basic incompatibility’ and infidelity’, ‘money issues’ is cited to be one of the leading cause of a couple’s decision to...February 7, 2020
Fitness App Makes Woman Lose Thousands of Dollars in Personal Injury Money!
Sharing information online is the ‘it’ thing for most people today. In fact, social media and its apps have given people...February 7, 2020